This church lighting project is a great case study. It demonstrates how developments in lighting technology offer new solutions to traditional problems.
St Mary The Virgin, Goldsborough is a beautiful Grade I listed church in the Knaresborough Benifice. It’s a wonderful old building with many significant features. It also presents the normal challenges of working on sensitive and significant buildings. Brilliant Lighting was commissioned to design the lighting in 2014.
There were multiple elements to the brief. The old church lighting was difficult to maintain; hard to reach halogen fittings needed continual lamp replacements. The existing lighting was functional but basic. It didn’t do a lot to highlight very special features of the church like the beautifully detailed old crusader tombs or the wonderful beamed roof. The church also wanted to improve the lighting for all the uses the building is put to. St Mary The Virgin is a popular wedding venue; it’s next door to Goldsborough Hall. As well as weddings the church wanted better, more flexible lighting for services, concerts and meetings.
High output LED fittings meet the need for reduced maintenance. The high quality fittings used throughout should last for many years even if used for a few hours each day. Which means the church wardens no longer have to make forays into the roof space with replacement lamps.
More challenging was fundamentally changing the character of the lighting while minimising the impact on the fabric of the building. The old church lighting was dominated by large halogen fittings in the roofspace. We wanted to introduce a more layered design with lighting for key features. We had to minimise additional cabling and the scheme uses entirely surface mounted fittings.
Before and After
Using Lighting Control to Manage LED
LED is best controlled with a lighting control system. The DALI dimming protocol can simplify the cabling architecture of a lighting design while maintaining flexibility. Here those three elements slot together beautifully. The lighting design uses LED throughout. The lighting is controlled by a Lutron HomeWorks QS lighting control system using Lutron’s DALI modules. HomeWorks QS and DALI together give us smooth LED dimming and as we will see, also gives us flexible lighting for different occasions in the church.
The surface mounted fittings at roof level are reasonably discreet. It’s more difficult to conceal fittings in full view but our range of options for mounting locations for the arches were limited.
We colour matched the finishes of the surface mounted fittings. We matched plaster and stone on site against RAL swatch cards on site and specified finishes for each fitting. The result is high output fittings that are incredibly recessive in-situ as can be seen in this shot of the fitting behind the altar. The tombs are lit with discreet, hidden LED fittings.
Church Lighting Scenes
One key element of the brief was flexibility. When we’re programming scenes for residential projects we’re typically thinking in terms of usage; Cooking, Dining etc. It’s not different for the lighting here but the occasions are rather different. We’ve programmed additional scenes for weddings, concerts and christenings as well as normal services. We’ll have more shots of this fabulous church live on the site here soon.
Case Study Photos
The Goldsborough Church Lighting Case Study is now online on this site.
Want to know more about the options for dimming and controlling LED? Have a look at The Lighting Buyer’s Technical Reference Guide.
Want to know more about Lighting Control and the various ways it works with great lighting design to make it better? See the Lighting Control section here.
Many thanks to the church wardens and everyone associated with St Mary The Virgin, Goldsborough. Thanks also to Stephen Calvert at Pearce Bottomley and the electrical team at Dave Barclay Electrical. Finally, thank you to Charlotte for the super photography.